Licensee found not guilty of liquor breach

24 February 2012

A New South Wales restaurant licensee who was fined by undercover police officers for serving liquor without food has successfully overturned the ruling in court.

In October 2010, two undercover police officers walked into the restaurant in Cronulla, Sydney, which had a standard restaurant licence. They sat at a table and ordered a round of drinks and the waitress left a food menu with them.

After half an hour they ordered a second round of drinks. They stayed another 50 minutes and finished their drinks before calling for the bill and leaving without ordering food.

Police then fined the licensee $1,100 for serving liquor without food.

After failing in a bid to overturn the ruling in Sutherland Local Court, the licensee appealed successfully to the District Court.

Judge Jonathan Williams found that the waitress would have reasonably expected the police officers to order food, as the premises were operating as a genuine restaurant, where meals were continuously being served. He said the officers had a menu placed before them and they did not do anything to suggest that they did not want food.

The lawyer acting for the licensee, Tony Hatzis of Hatzis Cusack Lawyers, said the decision was a victory for common sense.

"The judge accepted that pre-dinner and after dinner drinks are common in restaurants," he said.

"A restaurant licensee should not be convicted of an offence just because a patron decides to change his or her mind and leave the restaurant during pre-dinner drinks."

"It would be different, of course, if the restaurant staff had no intention of providing food to patrons," Hatzis added.

As Published on theshout.com.au on Fri, 24/02/2012

 

News & Articles

PRESENTATION BY TONY HATZIS TO THE LIQUOR AND GAMING 2018 CLE SEMINAR HELD AT UNSW
More

Paper presented by Tony Hatzis to the Liquor and Gaming 2017 CLE seminar held at UNSW
More

Paper presented by Tony Hatzis to the "Liquor and Gaming 2014" CLE seminar held at UNSW
More

Surprise packages in NSW reforms: Lawyer
More

Pub overturns 'staffies' prosecution
More

AHA(NSW) LEGAL AND INDUSTRIAL CONFERENCE
More

Paper presented by Tony Hatzis to the "Liquor and Gaming 2013" C.L.E. Seminar held at The Grace Hotel Sydney on 21 March 2013
More

Internet Retail Liquor Licence for sale of liquor to the public
More

Sale of liquor without meals in restaurants - Primary Service Authorisation
More

Karaoke Venue Liquor Licence
More

General Bar Hotel Liquor Licence
More

Small Bar Liquor Licence
More

Invitation for " Pubs: State of the Market" seminar held at AHA(NSW), Macquarie St, Sydney on June 20 2012
More

Tony's feature article in the May 2012 Law Society Journal on Liquor Licensing Traps and Complexities
More

Packaged Liquor Licence (Liquor Store/ Bottle Shop)
More

Lawyer's Three Strikes warning for pubs
More

Invitation for "Bill Evans on The Economy and Interest Rates in 2012"
More

Licensee found not guilty of liquor breach
More

Sports Facility/Sporting Venue Liquor Licence
More

...but Amended Laws 'Better for Industry'
More

Smoking Solutions - the Blacktown Workers test case
More

Judge bounces Police claim on security
More

Three Strikes but wrong Ballpark
More

Applications by the Police to the Director of Liquor and Gaming or the Liquor Authority to impose conditions.
More

Amendment to Liquor Regulation and CIS Process
More

2013 © Hatzis Cusack Lawyers

Powered by Splash Developments